(04-04-2025, 05:41 PM)KevinL Wrote: Pretty sure tunneling here is very tricky - high water table and a sandy base. Just the King underpass alone was tricky to engineer, and phase 2 is using mostly bridges for a reason.
Tunnelling isn't impossible with a high water table and sand it just changes how you tunnel. The largest difference you'll see is the type of TBM used. In the GTA you'll generally see EPB TBMs (Earth Pressure Balance TBM) which use the extracted fine soils (silts/clays) to maintain the pressure in front of the cutter head. The other common type used is a hard rock TBM which as the name suggests is designed to go through bedrock.
In KWs case since we have a lot of coarse soils (sand/gravel) you'd likely see a slurry TBM. With that said there are places in KW which have higher fine amounts. This could certainly pose a problem for a slurry TBM as the more fines the harder it is to seperate the excavated material from the slurry. This means reusing the slurry becomes a more challenging task.
Phase 2 is also mainly bridges because of the amount of rivers and train lines it has to cross, you'd have to be extremely deep to make a tunnel remotely feasible to pass under the Grand River which just doesn't make much sense when a bridge is way easier.

