07-12-2022, 05:32 AM
(07-11-2022, 05:06 PM)Bytor Wrote:(07-11-2022, 04:39 PM)danbrotherston Wrote: I think two things are being conflated here...over-engineered roads are different from overbuilt roads as we are discussing here.
Roads that are too wide, with too large corner radii are "over-engineered". Roads that are overbuilt have too many lanes for the traffic they carry. Like Westmount Rd. is extremely narrow...it is definitely not "over-engineered" but it is over built because it has four lanes.
Most of our roads are both however, and both cause problems and wasteful spending.
But your argument is true for road engineering--the standards the region sets are excessive.
But the choice to build four lane roads where they are not necessary is a policy choice...not an engineering choice--there are no standards requiring Highland Rd. to be four lanes. Engineers do have guides and standards that they use to try justify these decisions it is even more vague and handwavey than road standards, and if council directed them to, no engineer would put up an engineering fuss about building narrower roads like they do about deviating from "engineering standards".
Even more however, even by the standards the engineers use for roads the road we are discussing are actually still over built. Even by the most aggressive traffic modelling Highland Rd. does not justify four lanes. The choice to build four lanes is a policy choice from engineers who like building four lane roads.
I understand the differentiation that you are trying to make, but the source is still the same—adherence to manuals and standards that are out of date, through either being required to adhere by the employer or by pencil pushers unable to think independently. Whether that is "An AADT of 20,000 requires 4 lanes" (overbuilt) or "a residential road needs to be 50k/h and thus 13m from curb to curb with 2x3.5m travel lanes and 2x3m parking lanes" (over-engineered), the cause is the same.
But this simply isn't true.
There are no manuals no standards at the region, at the province, at a national level that require a road like Highland Rd. to have four lanes. This was fully acknowledged by regional staff. They said they prefer four lanes without any justification beyond a preference for four lane roads.