09-10-2018, 10:09 PM
The thing about the representation is that there is never a perfect system. Even if we elect representatives in direct proportion to the popular vote - individual issues have different levels of support. Just because somebody gets elected doesn't mean they have a mandate on each individual issue. Should we fix that issue too? Direct democracy?
So, I accept we have a not-so-perfect system. And really, I feel like every system is only as good as the citizens care to make it. Checks and balances (as we're seeing in the US as well) only work if citizens actually care that they work and punish people for violating them.
Using the notwithstanding clause here IS a big deal. It's directly against the norms we've lived with and it significantly weakens our democracy. I think that should be the focus at this point.
So, I accept we have a not-so-perfect system. And really, I feel like every system is only as good as the citizens care to make it. Checks and balances (as we're seeing in the US as well) only work if citizens actually care that they work and punish people for violating them.
Using the notwithstanding clause here IS a big deal. It's directly against the norms we've lived with and it significantly weakens our democracy. I think that should be the focus at this point.